SafeAuto vs. Liberty Mutual

Shopping for a new insurance carrier can be tough. There’s a lot to consider beyond just the price tag. The good news? You’re almost done choosing your new insurer. You’ve perused the websites of several car insurance companies, received recommendations from friends, and maybe even taken the time to compare car insurance quotes. You’ve narrowed it down to your final two choices: SafeAuto and…the other guys. Who’s it gonna be?

Why Should You Choose SafeAuto?

At SafeAuto, we value transparency as much as affordability. We hope this chart helps you decipher if SafeAuto or Liberty Mutual is a better fit to meet your insurance needs.

BBB Rating

SafeAuto

SafeAuto Insurance Group Inc. is rated A+ by the BBB.

VS

Liberty Mutual

A+

What Customers Say...

SafeAuto

“I have had Progressive, The General, GEICO and others and was not happy with their service or prices. So, I'm staying with SafeAuto.”

“SafeAuto helped me get good auto insurance in a time of need. Being dropped suddenly by Pr- er, my previous carrier after 12 years of loyalty certainly stung. But SafeAuto had my back and I won't forget it.”

VS

Liberty Mutual

“Very competitive pricing on premiums. Have received quality, honest, and professional service.”

“Insurance is great until you have to file a claim.”

These reviews are from consumers via the BBB or directly received from our own customers.

Do SafeAuto & Liberty Mutual Offer 24 Hour Customer Service?

SafeAuto

YES
Dial customer service 24/7 at 1 800 723-3288.

VS

Liberty Mutual

YES

Do SafeAuto & Liberty Mutual Provide SR-22 Insurance?

SafeAuto

YES
We do our best to provide you with the best rates for SR-22 car insurance from SafeAuto that is fast and easy, regardless of the reason.

VS

Liberty Mutual

YES

Are SafeAuto & Liberty Mutual Flexible To My Insurance Needs?

SafeAuto

Flexible, fast.
Not every carrier understands if your needs are month to month. That’s why we offer low down payments and flexible policies so you can choose the best car insurance coverage for your situation no matter how often it changes.

VS

Liberty Mutual

Flexible

How Long Does It Take To Get A Quote?

SafeAuto

3 minutes.
Get a quote in three minutes or less and get back on the road same day online or with the help of our trained specialists.

VS

Liberty Mutual

Online quoting in a few minutes

What Discounts Do SafeAuto & Liberty Mutual Offer?

SafeAuto

Multi-Vehicle
New Business Transfer
Homeowner
Driver Improvement Course

And more…

VS

Liberty Mutual

Multi-Car
Pay-In-Full
Accident-Free
Homeowners
Military

This is not an exhaustive list of every discount offered. Discounts may vary by state. Call and discuss which discount options may apply to your situation with your insurance carrier.

What Are SafeAuto's & Liberty Mutual's Specialties?

SafeAuto

State-minimum insurance coverage
High-risk auto insurance

As a legal requirement, we believe everyone should have access to the insurance they need to get back on the road safely. It’s our pleasure to help drivers with less-than-perfect records get the coverage they need at a price they can afford.

VS

Liberty Mutual

Large global property and casualty insurer

What Insurance Offerings Do SafeAuto & Liberty Mutual Provide?

SafeAuto

Auto
Renters and Homeowners
Motorcycle
And more.
We can help you find the insurance you need, whether it’s auto insurance, property insurance, or health insurance.

VS

Liberty Mutual

Auto
Property
Life
Business and more…

This is not an exhaustive list of every product offered by each insurance company.

What Payment Options Do Liberty Mutual & SafeAuto Offer?

SafeAuto

Online, phone, mail, app

Explore your payment options.
We also offer low down payments and billing plans to better accommodate your needs – just call and ask what is available in your state.

VS

Liberty Mutual

Online, phone, mail, app

Are You Ready To Commit?

Now that you’ve completed your research, you’re almost done selecting your new carrier. You’ve done your best to compare SafeAuto to Liberty Mutual, and now, you’re ready to select the best car insurance for your situation, whatever it may be.

We’re proud to provide insurance to anyone who needs insurance, regardless of their driving record, and we would be just as proud to serve you, too. There’s nothing standing between you and affordable coverage anymore.

Please note the information included on this page was last updated in October 2020.

SafeAuto Is Proud To Be The Insurance For The Rest Of Us.

Flexible plans and affordable state minimum coverage? Now that’s insurance for the rest of us. Have a question for us at SafeAuto? Need to start your policy? Just want to talk? Call us at 1-800-SAFEAUTO to speak to a real person, not a robot, any time or email us at CustomerService@SafeAuto.com. For common questions, please consult our FAQ page.